Tuesday, May 30, 2006
These mist covered mountains...
New Zealand mountaineer, Mark Inglis, a paraplegic has conquered Everest. In the world today, amputee's are displaying an amazing spirit. Life has dealt them a hard time, but they have risen to the challenge. His plight can be an inspiration for all of us, showing that with dedication we can make any of our problems easier to deal with. It all starts with a positive outlook. It continues with a spirit which defies the odds. It concludes with action in the face of overwhelming adversity. One has to admire sombody with that kind of spirit. I hope you can feel uplifted today. As a motivational speaker, and co-owner of PeakFuels, an energy bar company, he extolls the virtues of "take it to the next level." On his success he says "nobody can take away what I achieved." Inspirational. The view from the top is supposed to be amazing. He enjoyed it. Doesn't that make you feel good? Honestly. No matter how bad or hard our day has become, there are others not as well off as we are and we should make the most of what we have.
Let us put things in perspective. And yes, perspective is what I would like to discuss today. Some would say that when you have a goal, you push aside any distractions and focus on it. Inglis did this. Perspective. Reaching a goal, especially an important goal is paramount. Reaching your goal by neglecting others is another story. This Mark Inglis abandoned a dying man, David Sharp, as he stormed towards the summit. Perspective. In other media reports it was described as "summit fever." Forty climbers refused to stop and help because the dying man, was, according to Inglis, "effectively dead." Now when I read an account of this tragedy, I waited, reserving judgement, because there are those, that like to discredit people who make something of themselves. I read with sceptisism. And Inglis sounded like he deserved the benefit of the doubt. " It was a very hard decision. We couldn't do anything. He had no oxygen, no proper gloves, things like that. To get David (Sharp) down would have taken 20 sherpas, and he would have died on the way down." It was also said that Sharp was frost bitten so badly, he could only move his eyes. The 34yr old, in good physical condition was no match for the treacherous conditions at Everest. She claims lives every year. Mother Nature can be cruel. Now let us dig a little bit deeper. Inglis said that Sharp didn't have proper gloves. Really? It can cost as much as $75,000 for proper support, in the commercial plight Everest has become. Inglis, a motiviational speaker was sponsored by an Australian engineering firm to the tune of fifty thousand. His other high profile sponsors included Suzuki, Paralympics New Zealand, and others. Team Inglis was determined to succeed. Now, if I was missing two legs I would make sure I had proper support. Yeah, I would buy proper gloves too. David Sharp didn't have enough oxygen bottles either. Was he a champion of a person, pushing himself to the limits, living his goals but failing in that huge aspect of not having much money? Were his gloves a little cheaper, but his ambiton a little deeper. He passed away only 300 meters from the summit, hiding from the elements, spent, alone, cold. And not far away others celebrated, a life long goal. Perspective. The winners were only 300 meters away. And then they walked away. Now am I being too hard on Mr Inglis? How did Mark become a paraplegic? He was rescued after being trapped in a cave for 14 days because of a blizzard. His rescuers risked their lives to rescue him. Sir Edmund Hillary, ( familiar name? google it ) says, " I haven't seen any evidence so far that this chap hiding under a rock was in a hopeless conditon." He would know. Hillary added that, " I don't think it matters a damn if he was from another party, if he was Swiss or from Timbuktu or whatever. He was a human being, and we would regard it as our duty to get him back to safety." For myself, and as one of you says quite often, this is only one man's opinion, I won't be buying any PeakFuel energy bars. Am I out to lunch? He may have died anyways like it was said, and then all the efforts would have been for naught. What do you think?
http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,3682716a11,00.html ---( this is a tame interview with Inglis as I didn't want to choose most of the other "biased" reports )---
We had another report here, about a man, Lincoln Hall, left for dead by his support group because he had become delirious, due to lack of oxygen. He did make it to the top and was on his way down. It was released on the Everest new web sites that his death was verified, due to cerebral oedema, or swelling of the brain. An American, Dan Mazur, found Mr Hall still clinging to life and he abandoned his climb, giving him hot tea, and some of his oxygen. To make another long story brief. He lived.
http://www.mounteverest.net/ <---- this is a good site.
http://www.seeklyrics.com/lyrics/Dire-Straits/Brothers-In-Arms.html wish i could play the song BUT... that would be illegal, and its an old crummy one anyways. I have always wondered what that song is about.... can you help me.
(sorry about the errors in this one.... )
Chanks.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
14 comments:
read this.
http://www.mounteverest.net/news.php?id=3302
rob hall died a hero. Lincoln Hall made it on his second attempt. good article
great blog!
Chanks, my dad used to say when you think you have troubles, listen to someone elses and yours don't seem so bad. Good advice eh?
AV
Hey chankslee, an idiot has a question for ya! Is there a secret message in the fact that the title of your latest entry is "These mist covered mountains..." and yet when you look at the picture, even if you zoom in reeeeeal close, even if you spend a half hour examining little bits and pieces of the picture, you can't actually find any mist any-freakin-where? What does it mean? Who is this hidden clue referring to and what does it say about them? Why don't you make it a trivia question to see if anyone can guess who I am just from what I've written so far here?
(and yes, the blog is extremely interesting. I saw this in the newspaper and they didn't give it any perspective at all, unlike your very well-considered thoughts)
WOW This was a good blog writing today Chanks....
It really made me stop and think. Remember,, Lord of the Flies? For some reason I think of the correlation between Nature VS Nurture when I hear abour how human beings are being treated. In one breath we jump attacking those who didn't care enough to stop and help this poor ill prepared man who wished to fight for the summit. Was he so uneducated that he had no idea what he was doing? Was this his first and last attempt to reach the summit?
OR was this a man who prepared as much as he could who knew the risks that were there upon climbing this mountain? Think for a moment about all the things you have a passion for and try to imagine others with the same passion as you for something. I think that if I were the type (and yes it's a big jump and a big if) who had a passion for climbing mount everest, I would dilligently prepare, I would do some smaller climbs as I prepared for my big attempt. I would gather all I needed and I would head up 150% ready to succeed. If along the way I realized that there was no way I would make it, I would tell others to leave me, go succeed and accomplish that goal, I know the drive you have for it. I don't want to be your burden, here take my gloves, my oxygen, my jacket, go and remember me and succeed.
My passion to want success would over flow into a passion for others to succeed, I would want to go out fighting.
tsk tsk tsk Chanks
After reading your blog, then reading the song lyrics, there is no way that you can tell me that you don't quite understand the words of this song.
Together as ppl united with one passion we live life together. We perservere to accomplish our goals knowing that somewhere there is someone else who has the same passions as us and we have a thread that has invisibley tied us together and united us. Even when alone we know that we are not alone. We walk a path together, remembering that we share a commonality, that we need their strength to help us conquer something, that we would be silly to allow something so small to come between us and the bigger picture at hand. Don't worry about me if I fail you must go forth remembering their are others who need you, and remember that what may look like failure to others is success to me.
I think the song is about someone who has died and who can no longer succeed in his passion but still hungers for others to succeed and doesn't want them to be held back b/c of him.......
Needless to say we know that Mark Inglis isn't a good samaritan. Do you get the feeling the media is holding Inglis responsible for this in- humane crime? Why him and not the other 40 climbers that passed Mr. Sharp as he lay dying?
That was quite some fever.
I would like to make a few quotes if I may.
"They (Inglis and his team members)shared their oxygen supplies with him and radioed their expedition manager Russell Bryce for advice. But they were told nothing could be done for him and, concerned for their own safety, they were forced to make the tragic decision to leave Mr Sharp to die." also
'We radioed. Russ said, "Look, you can't do anything. He's been there x number of hours without oxygen. He's effectively dead." '
So the question here is not who was to blame but what was morally right. And by who and what standards do we define morally?
So, are we back to the quote? "It is but one mans opinion."
Sharp had been robbed by other climbers? Read the first link on this comment page. all of it. One sherpa tried to help, while this man was crying, and trying to stand. we only know he was effectivly dead because someone at the base camp said he was. lincoln hall was supposed to be dead too but he got some help and lived. newbie is right no good samaritains in the group of 40 on everest. How would you like inglis as your climbing partner?
Just a short note re: previous blog.
Dadost, I concede. At least for now.
Spaghet
Hey Spaghet, Thanks for your concession. I can sleep in peace now.
You remind me of a race horse I once bet on. The name of the horse was "Hoof Hearted".
I think you know "Hoof Hearted" and if you don't just ask someone close to you if they know "Hoof Hearted", they will tell you for sure.
Really sad, those mountain climbers.
After much soul searching, I have come to the conclusion that I will have to agree with Newbie. Everything boils down to ones own thoughts. First I thought "what a bunch of heartless selfish people to leave that man to die". Then I thought "what and idiot Sharp was to go so unprepared". And so on and so on. I'm sure you get the picture.
As for Tara's comments well personally I know I would be screaming "DON"T LEAVE ME" whether it be verbally or with just my eye movement. I have a very strong instinct to survive. I don't think anyone wants to die and I am sure that is what those forty people thought as they past Sharp. Helping him could very well have been the end for them. What I do know is that me in that situation would determine my values.
AV
How sad. It is my understanding that Sharp climbed the mountain solo and was on his way down from the summit. It is said other climbers passed him as he 'STRUGGLED TO SURVIVE' I can't quite picture an 'effectively dead man' strugging to do anything.
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20060525/everest_death_060525/20060525?hub=World
Me
Hey Dadost
I too once bet on a horse, its name was "Ife Arted" butt it was neck and neck with your horse "Hoof Harted" The announcers had a heck of a time trying to get around that one. "Well we're coming up to the last stretch and its Hoof Harted, Ife Arted, Hoof Harted, Ife Arted..." But when they crossed the finished line everyone knew Hoof Harted.
There is more to be proud of and commended for in hiking halfway up a mountain to save someone's life than there is in hiking to the top just to brag about it.
Post a Comment